Project Name: Kerb Construction Project at Fison Ave West
Auditable Category |
WBS ID and Item Description |
Applicable metrics |
||
1. |
Performance / Progress (Estates Services, 2017) |
1.1 |
Change in cost during the project life cycle due to increase in resource shortage |
Yes, the baseline cost had to be revised once |
No, the cost was never changed from its budget |
||||
1.2 |
Change in cost performance index |
Yes, the cost performance index (CPI) got below 1 |
||
No, CPI never reached below 1 |
||||
1.3 |
Change in scope during the project life cycle |
Yes, scope increased for twice instances |
||
No, scope was same since the planning stage of the project |
||||
2. |
Compliance (TechTarget, 2015) |
2.1 |
The change in cost was due to shortage of resources and even increase in scope, so was the change control system used for the approval of change request |
Yes, the path described in change control management plan was followed |
No, the management plan was neglected and not followed at all instances |
||||
2.2 |
All the statutory compliances were obtained from the authorities for the project |
Yes, the request letter or application was approved by local authorities |
||
No, the request was not approved at first go |
||||
3. |
Quality (Shah, 2011) |
3.1 |
The Kerb was built as per the defined standard in contract |
Yes, kerbs was built by strictly following the standards |
No, it could not be built, at very few instance there were lapse in quality, however proper rectification was attended |
||||
3.2 |
Was the CV (Cost Variance) could be maintained positive throughout the project |
Yes, CV was +ve for the whole life cycle |
||
No, CV could not be maintained +ve throughout |
||||
3.3 |
Was the SV (Schedule Variance) could be maintained positive throughout the project |
Yes, SV was +ve for the whole life cycle |
||
No, SV could not be maintained +ve throughout |
||||
4. |
Change / Exit (Microsoft, 2017) |
4.1 |
The purchase of Kerb road furniture was concluded properly by submitting the procurement documents too |
Yes, all the items as per contract supplied and documentation also completed |
No, the items are delivered as per contract, but the documentation was not submitted fully |
||||
4.2 |
The safety item supply and installation contractor has installed all the items at site |
Yes, the contractor has installed successfully and all contractual closure documentation submitted |
||
The installation are done but final document submission after quality check is pending yet |
||||
5. |
Risk (Accounting-Simplified, 2013) |
5.1 |
All the risks are responded according to the response plan developed earlier |
Yes, all the risks responses are applied to the threats |
No, all the risks responses were not applied |
||||
5.2 |
All the identified opportunities are explored to enhance the occurrence probability and impact |
Yes, all the identified opportunities are enhanced |
||
No, the opportunities were neglected and no effort was made to enhance them |
||||
6. |
Best Practices / Lessons to be Learned (Project Smart, 2017) |
6.1 |
Always the execution planning need to be done with keeping rainy season in mind and work should not be planned in this time to avoid any delay compared to baseline |
Yes, the criteria was considered while planning the execution phase |
No, the criteria was not considered for planning |
||||
6.2 |
Procurement of critical items like safety must be started in advance to avoid last moment rush and do extra expenditure |
Yes, the procurement was done at early stage itself to save time and money both |
||
No, the procurement was not done at early stage |
Audit Category |
Item |
When will it be conducted? |
Who will conduct? |
Purpose (discovery or decision-making)? |
Performance / Progress |
1.1 |
Cost audit after the approval of change order |
Project Manager & Sponsor |
Decision-making |
1.2 |
Monthly audit |
Project Manager |
Decision-making |
|
1.3 |
Audit change request status |
Project Manager |
Decision-making |
|
Compliance |
2.1 |
Audit change request status |
Project Manager |
Decision-making |
2.2 |
Quarterly audit |
Senior Executive, Contractor Farm, |
Discovery |
|
Quality |
3.1 |
Quality Audit, as per request |
Project Manager |
Discovery |
3.2 |
Monthly audit |
Project Manager |
Decision-making |
|
3.3 |
Monthly audit |
Project Manager |
Decision-making |
|
Change / Exit |
4.1 |
Procurement Audit in-between the progress & last one after the task ends |
Senior executive, Contractor Farm |
Discovery |
4.2 |
Monthly Audit in-between the progress & last one after the task ends |
Senior executive, Contractor Farm |
Discovery |
|
Risk |
5.1 |
Monthly audit |
Project Manager |
Discovery |
5.2 |
Monthly audit |
Project Manager |
Discovery |
|
Best Practices / Lessons to be Learned |
6.1 |
Monthly Audit in-between the progress & last one after the task ends |
Project Manager |
Decision-making |
6.2 |
Monthly Audit in-between the progress & last one after the task ends |
Project Manager |
Decision-making |
Controllable Category |
Item & Explanation |
PMBOK Knowledge Area |
||
Input |
Tool & Technique |
Output |
||
1. Deliverable |
1.1 Delivery of road safety items got delayed |
Progress status report |
Audit |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset |
The delivery of items required to maintain the proper safety at site got delayed due to an accident at their shop |
||||
1.2 Overhead for the job increased due to allowance of doing night shift job only |
Progress status report |
Audit |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset |
|
During pre-monsoon and post-monsoon seasons the rains were showering mostly at night only, so the duration increased with getting any work done and hence the change in cost has happened |
||||
1.3 Because of change in scope of work, the requirement of the safety item also changed |
Progress status report |
Audit & Scope verification |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset |
|
Since the scope of work got increased due to the change in route of the bypass road which was required for maintaining extra safety during night work and concreting using boom placer, the scope and as well their supporting items also got changed |
||||
2. Configuration |
2.1 The written approval letter for the kerbs at road junctions wanted to increase the width of bypass road and improve the quality bit more to allow passage of heavy load vehicles too |
Requirement documents, Scope Statement |
Audit & Scope verification |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset & change in scope |
Due to rain the shoulders of the road got washed out, so the design of the road width was enhanced and the compaction ration requirement too. So it was a change in scope and obviously needed additional time and cost to complete. |
||||
3. Status Accounts |
3.1 Earned value analysis |
Earned Value Analysis |
Audit |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset |
The SPI, CPI, SV, CV and EAC need to be checked before the termination to ensure the trend of progress the party could maintain throughout the project |
||||
4. Logs |
4.1 Site visit need to be done to take photographs of the completed works |
Site Status Report |
Audit |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset |
The finished job was required to be photographed for including with the close-out report which is required to be submitted to Tejas Mehta, TMR |
||||
5. Issues |
5.1 There was delay in obtaining the approval from local authorities |
Requirement documents |
Audit |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset |
As discussed in point 2.1 in this section, the approval was delayed due to want of change in scope |
||||
6. Procurements |
6.1 Site construction work completed successfully |
Baseline Schedule |
Audit |
Updated documentation and store in organisational asset |
The site work was delayed due to the intervention of different aspects like change in scope, increase in quality standards, etc. |
After the job completion is declared by the site team for construction of Kerbs, the different forms of audit and inspection (as discussed in above points) were used to confirm the job completion and document the changes happened during the process in different knowledge area of scope, time, quality, resources etc. Now, the overall project team need to concentrate to close the project as per below schedule for different category of item. The site execution head need to certify the completion of job at site and Procurement in-charge the receipt of overall documentation required for final closure. Once all the job completion assurance and final documentation received, the contract can be closed by providing a closure certificate.
Gantt chart:
Gantt chart provided with EVM assignment is unmanageable. Student is requested to please paste it from the earlier file he has developed.
Closure schedule:
Communication for closure:
Activity / Milestone List |
Start Date |
End Date |
Whom to inform regarding closure |
Overall Responsibility of closure confirmation |
What is required to be inspected |
Final closure documentation |
Closure activity of Supply of Kerb Furniture |
1-Sep 2017 |
10-Sep 2017 |
Furniture supplier |
Procurement Manager / Project Manager |
Supply scope document, Installation completion certificate, final documentation |
Closure certificate |
Closure activity of Concreting activity |
5-Sep 2017 |
14-Sep 2017 |
Concrete supplier |
Construction Manager / Project Manager |
Scope document, Execution completion certificate, final documentation |
Closure certificate |
Closure activity of all miscellaneous works like cleaning of site & removal of temporary safety items |
9-Sep 2017 |
18-Sep 2017 |
Labour supplier |
Construction Manager / Project Manager |
Scope document, Execution completion certificate, final documentation |
Closure certificate |
References
Accounting-Simplified. (2013). Audit Risk Model Inherent Risk, Control Risk & Detection Risk. Retrieved September 8, 2017, from https://accounting-simplified.com: https://accounting-simplified.com/audit/risk-assessment/audit-risk.html
Estates Services. (2017). The Key Performance Indicator Evaluation Process (KPI Process). Retrieved September 8, 2017, from www.admin.ox.ac.uk: https://www.admin.ox.ac.uk/media/global/wwwadminoxacuk/localsites/estatesservices/documents/capitalprojects/KPI_Process_Guidance_Note.pdf
Microsoft. (2017). Audit Policy. Retrieved September 8, 2017, from https://technet.microsoft.com: https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc766468(v=ws.10).aspx
Project Smart. (2017). A Cost-Effective Project Management Tool. Retrieved September 8, 2017, from
https://www.projectsmart.co.uk: https://www.projectsmart.co.uk/lessons-learned.php
Shah, D. (2011, December 19). Quality audit. Retrieved September 8, 2017, from www.slideshare.net:
TechTarget. (2015, March). compliance audit. Retrieved September 7, 2017, from TechTarget:
https://searchcompliance.techtarget.com/definition/compliance-audit
Essay Writing Service Features
Our Experience
No matter how complex your assignment is, we can find the right professional for your specific task. Contact Essay is an essay writing company that hires only the smartest minds to help you with your projects. Our expertise allows us to provide students with high-quality academic writing, editing & proofreading services.Free Features
Free revision policy
$10Free bibliography & reference
$8Free title page
$8Free formatting
$8How Our Essay Writing Service Works
First, you will need to complete an order form. It's not difficult but, in case there is anything you find not to be clear, you may always call us so that we can guide you through it. On the order form, you will need to include some basic information concerning your order: subject, topic, number of pages, etc. We also encourage our clients to upload any relevant information or sources that will help.
Complete the order formOnce we have all the information and instructions that we need, we select the most suitable writer for your assignment. While everything seems to be clear, the writer, who has complete knowledge of the subject, may need clarification from you. It is at that point that you would receive a call or email from us.
Writer’s assignmentAs soon as the writer has finished, it will be delivered both to the website and to your email address so that you will not miss it. If your deadline is close at hand, we will place a call to you to make sure that you receive the paper on time.
Completing the order and download