Whenever a person or a group of person think and decides to establish a business, they have many of the choices. Certain kinds of business structures are there that a person can use for his/her business. A business structure depends on the factor that how many people are going to manage the same. Mainly three type of business structure is used by the business and that are Sole Proprietorship, Partnership, and Company. This is to state that a sole Proprietorship concern can be used as a business model only in the circumstance where a single person wants to establish and operate a business. In the case of two or more persons, the later two terms are used. Every business structure has some advantages and disadvantages, which are defined hereunder.
A partnership firm is a group of two or more person who comes together for an economic purpose and decided to share the profits and loss thereof among themselves. In a partnership firm, the owners are known as partners of the firm and they make decisions for their business according to the power granted under “partnership agreement”. In general, the partnership is a closed structure and does not allow interference of public. A partnership can be limited and unlimited. Unlimited Partnership is also known as a traditional partnership. In such a kind of partnership, the liabilities of the partners are unlimited and their personal properties can be used to pay the debts of their business i.e. partnership firm. Whereas on the other side, a limited partnership has the same characteristics as a traditional partnership, however, this structure has some benefits. Under a Limited Partnership, the liabilities of partners are limited up to the level of their investment. If nothing is mentioned about the type of partnership, in general, it is assumed that partners are into a traditional partnership. Similar to any other business structure a partnership firm has some pros and cons that as follow:-
As mentioned above this can be stated that although partnership is an easy mode to establish a business, yet the same certain limitations.
After the partnership, this is also a type of business structure as mentioned earlier. In comparison to the partnership, a company is more organized. A well-defined legislation is applicable on every company according to the nation in that such company gets incorporate. A company can be termed as an association of two or more than two person who comes together for a commercial purpose (BusinessDictionary, 2018). Unlike a partnership firm, in a company management and ownership are with two different bodies such as directors and members of the company. Similar to a partnership, there are different types of companies. Companies can be private or public. A private company is closely held companies and the public cannot be a member of such companies, whereas, in a public company, any person can become a member by purchasing it is shares.
On the other side, in terms of liability, companies can be divided into two kinds such as a limited company and unlimited company. In a limited company, liabilities of members are limited up to the level of their investment. In case of an unlimited company, members will be held unlimitedly liable and their personal assets can be called upon in case of winding up of the company. In addition to this, a public company can further divide into listed and unlisted company. A listed company is the one, that has it is shares listed on a recognized stock exchange (Khatri, 2011). This is a more open business structure as any person can become a member of the company by purchasing shares from the open market. An unlisted company, as the name implies does not have any stock or share registered on the stock exchange. Regardless of the type of company, some basic common advantages and disadvantages of the same are mentioned as follow:-
Conclusion
As in the given case, three persons are there, therefore they cannot go for Sole Proprietorship, concern. They have to options for their business structure in the form of partnership and company. As provided in the problem scenario, that John, Tom, and Raj want to keep their business strictly limited up to them; in such a situation, a company will not be helpful for them. As mentioned above that in the case of a company, authorities have significant control over the affair of the business, hence this form of business is not suggested to John, Tom, and Raj. Further, they can go for partnership firm, however, as they want to keep their liability limited up to a level, for this reason, the model of Limited Liability partnership is suggested to them. By adopting this business structure, all of their requirement will be satisfied.
Issues
In the given case, Sue and her mother were walking in a housing estate and then heard some voice of dogs barking. Sue noticed that gate was closed but the same was not latched. As soon as Sue and her mother passed by the gate, two dogs came outside of the gate and tried to bite Sue and her mother. Although, the dogs did not bite any one of them, yet the cause of this sudden incident, Sue’s mother got a heart attack and died. Now the issue is to check that whether the owners of the dogs Mr. Peter will be held liable to pay damages in the case or not?
Under Tort Law, if a person commits a civil wrong in respect of other then he/she will be held liable. Tort or Civil wrong action of a person may be intentional or unintentional. An unintentional tort is an act that a person does without any knowledge and malafide intention and such acts are commonly known as “Negligence”. Under Tort Law, negligence is a situation where a person who owns a civil liability and duty of care in respect of other and such person breach this liability or duty (Legal Services Commission of South Australia, 2018). The concept of negligence has developed in the area of Tort Law to provide a safeguard to those who suffer from damages due to the negligence of another person. According to the decision given in the case of Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562 this is necessary to mention that only breach of a duty of care is not enough, the other person must come out with some loss cause of such breach. It is to be stated that the loss accrued to the claimant in the cases of negligence must be a direct result of the negligence act of the defendant.
Under Negligence, remoteness of damage is an important factor to discuss. It was held in the case of Re Polemis & Furness Withy & Company ltd. [1921]3 KB 560 that the damages must be a direct consequence of the act of the defendant (E-lawresources, 2018). Therefore, in a summaries way, this can be stated that the following conditions are needed to be satisfied in the cases of negligence:-
Losses can come in any form, such as personal injury, property damages, economic loss, or psychiatric injury.
In addition to aforesaid, the defense is also an important aspect under Tort Law. Contributory Negligence is a circumstance, where the claimant fails to take reasonable care of him/her and such carelessness proved as a supporting reason of accident. In cases of Contributory negligence, the Burdon of proof lies with the defendant and if the same proves the presence of Contributory negligence, then the defendant will be entitled to pay the reduced damages to the claimant.
In the given case, Sue and her mother were walking in a housing estate. Soon they both have heard the noise of dogs barking from the side of a house. Being the owner of the dog, it was the civil liability of Peter to provide a safeguard to the outsider and passengers thereon from the dogs. Peter, in this case, was required to latch the gate, as he was aware of the fact that he has two dogs and keeping them unchained can cause an accident to anyone. Later on, when the dogs were barking, Sue has seen that the door of the house was closed from those dogs were barking. In addition to this, Sue has also noticed that the gate was not locked. When Sue went near to the house with her mother from where the dogs were barking, dogs have come out from the house and tried to attack sue and her mother. In this situation, sue screamed and by listening to her scream, Peter came out and controlled the dogs before they would attack Sue or her mother. Peter acted like a reasonable person here and prevented the possible accident that could accrue in the absence of immediate action that Peter has taken. Although, the action of Peter has saved Sue and her mother from a physical injury, however due to all these events Sue’s mother suffered from a heart attack as she felt a sudden shock and due to the heart attack, she died.
Applying the rules of Tort Law, Sue’s mother got a personal injury due to the negligence of Peter. Regardless of the fact that Peter has put the reasonable efforts to stop the accident, the loss has accrued to Sue’s mother ultimately. Applying to Re Polemis & Furness Withy & Company ltd. There was a direct connection between the whole incident and Sue’s mother. Further, all the conditions as stated in the case of Donoghue v Stevenson has satisfied here. Although Peter can take help of Contributory Negligence in this case as Sue already knew that door was not locked, still she and her mother still moved out towards the house.
Conclusion
In order to conclude the issue, this can be stated that Sue is a claimant in the case who can ask for the damages on behalf of her mother to Peter. As Peter was the owner of the dogs, it was his liability to keep the caution towards the passengers and every outsider. Peter did not take any precaution but prevent the accident at the moment. He acted like a reasonable person but fails to perform the duty of care by letting the dogs unchained and door unlatched. In addition to Peter, Sue and her mother also failed to take their care as they continued towards the door even after knowing the same was just closed and dogs could come outside at any time. In such as situation Peter is liable to pay the damages but the amount of damages will be reduced cause of Contributory negligence on the part of sue and her mother.
References
Accountingtools. (2017). Corporation advantages and disadvantages. Retrieved from: https://www.accountingtools.com/articles/corporation-advantages-and-disadvantages.html
BusinessDictionary. (2018). Company. Retrieved from: https://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/company.html
Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562
E-lawresources. (2018). Remoteness of damage. Retrieved from: https://e-lawresources.co.uk/Remoteness-of-damage.php
Glasgow, F. (2011). Small Business Finance All-in-One For Dummies. England: John Wiley & Sons.
Khatri, D., K. (2011). Financial Accounting. India: Tata McGraw-Hill Education.
law-right.com. (2018). The separation between ownership and control in companies: a key to success? Retrieved from: https://www.law-right.com/the-separation-between-ownership-and-control-in-companies/
Legal services Commission of South Australia. (2018). What is negligence? Retrieved from: https://www.lawhandbook.sa.gov.au/ch29s05s01.php
Re Polemis & Furness Withy & Company ltd. [1921]3 KB 560
Strong, S. I. & Williams, L. (2011). Complete Tort Law: Text, Cases, & Materials. (2nd ed). New York: OUP Oxford.
Essay Writing Service Features
Our Experience
No matter how complex your assignment is, we can find the right professional for your specific task. Contact Essay is an essay writing company that hires only the smartest minds to help you with your projects. Our expertise allows us to provide students with high-quality academic writing, editing & proofreading services.
Free Features
Free revision policy
$10Free bibliography & reference
$8Free title page
$8Free formatting
$8How Our Essay Writing Service Works
First, you will need to complete an order form. It's not difficult but, in case there is anything you find not to be clear, you may always call us so that we can guide you through it. On the order form, you will need to include some basic information concerning your order: subject, topic, number of pages, etc. We also encourage our clients to upload any relevant information or sources that will help.
Complete the order form
Once we have all the information and instructions that we need, we select the most suitable writer for your assignment. While everything seems to be clear, the writer, who has complete knowledge of the subject, may need clarification from you. It is at that point that you would receive a call or email from us.
Writer’s assignment
As soon as the writer has finished, it will be delivered both to the website and to your email address so that you will not miss it. If your deadline is close at hand, we will place a call to you to make sure that you receive the paper on time.
Completing the order and download