Part A
Answer 1: concept related to phoenix activity is usually reflected with the idea of a second company, in which it is newly incorporated. This new company is generated from the ashes of its failed predecessor in which both controllers and business of the second company are same.
In other words, phoenix activity means incorporating a new company for the purpose of takeover the insolvent business of a predecessor company. The legal concept of phoenix activity is the genuine failure and liquidation of the company. There are two forms of phoenix activity that are legal and illegal:
Answer 2: if controller conducts legal phoenix activity then only it is beneficial for the society, but in case illegal phoenix activity is conducted by the controller then situation is completely different. Phoenix activity is considered as illegal when controller incorporated new company for the purpose of continues the business of old company which has intentionally liquidated for the purpose of avoid the payments of the debts.
It must be noted that illegal phoenix activity impacts all the stakeholders of the company such as business community, employees, contractors, government and environment in following manner.
It must be noted that phoenix activity not only affect above stated stakeholders, but it also affects the whole society by depriving the funds which can be distributed to the hospitals, schools, roads, etc. various measures are taken by government for the purpose of reducing this activity such as by punishing the offenders as per the law (ASIC, 2016).
Answer 3: the main purpose of phoenix activity is to provide the way for winding up the company, rather than deregister the company by ASIC. This activity also allowed the employees to assist the government for the purpose of getting their entitlements from the failed companies. However, it must be noted that this purpose only reduces some side effects of the phoenix activity, and not eliminate the concept itself.
The other purpose of phoenix activity is to reduce the cost of the liquidation, and it also increase the speed of liquidation process by removing the procedure of filing application.
However, there are some other purposes also which are stated below:
Answer 4: Generally, directors and other owners of the business get the benefit from phoenix activity because they incorporate the new company and get rid from all their liabilities in the old company. This new company starts their new business and free from old liabilities. Assets of the old company are transferred in the new company, and Controllers of the previous business choose this move to start their business in a new way by leaving the creditors, employees, and government unpaid.
This activity is not beneficial for creditors, employees, government, and society in many ways, and some of these ways are stated below:
Answer 5: phoenix activity is not inherently illegal, and there is no express prohibition imposed by Corporation Act 2001 on Phoenix activity. Action conducted under phoenix context is considered as illegal when intention of the directors includes detriment of the interest of creditors and other stakeholders of the business. Wrongdoing on part of the directors is considered and whether directors breach any other law. Phoenix activity is considered as long standing issue, and various solutions are proposed for the purpose of solving this issue. Therefore, it is clear that there is no specific section in the corporation Act 2001 which specifically prohibits the phoenix activity.
Answer 6: yes, some sections of the corporation Act 2001 are breached by the phoenix activity, and these sections are stated below:
Section 180 of the Corporation Act 2001 impose duty on the directors and other officers of the organization to perform their duties and exercise their powers with due care and diligence that any reasonable person would exercise if they were the director or officer of the organization or hold the office of the director or officer of the company and had same responsibilities in the company.
This section further states that director or other officer of the company satisfy the above stated requirements while making any judgment of the business, if they:
It must be noted that belief of the director that judgment made by them is in the best interest of the company is considered as rational if any reasonable person in that situation holds the similar belief (Corporation Act, 2001).
In case of phoenix activity, directors breach their duty under section 180 because they fail to perform their duties and exercise their powers with due care and diligence that any reasonable person would exercise. Directors also fail to make business judgment in good faith and in the best interest of the company.
Section 181 of the Corporation Act 2001 states, directors or other officers of the corporation must perform their duties and exercise their powers in good faith and in the best interest of the company. These section further states, director must perform their duties and exercise their powers for the proper purpose.
This subsection is civil penalty provision under section 1317E, and if any person contravenes subsection 1 of this section then such person contravenes complete section.
Directors of the company breach section 181 if they engage in illegal phoenix activity because they fail to make business judgment for proper purpose (Corporation Act, 2001).
Answer 7: ASIC v Somerville [2009] NSWSC 934- in this case, NSW Supreme Court held that solicitor was also guilty for abetting the directors of the company to breach their duties by engaging in the Phoenix activity. This case was considered as warning for all those directors who were advising for business restructuring, to take care that they were not step their legal and financial duties while restructuring their business.
A fact of the case- Mr. Somerville was a solicitor, and he provides advice to the various directors of the company who are facing financial difficulties in their organization. Almost 8 defendants get such advice from the solicitor and some of them come back even two or three times. In every case Mr. Somerville provide advice to the director so that:
In this case, Court deals with the issue of phoenix activity, and it was the only case in which lawyer was also punished in this way. Civil penalty provisions were issued by ASIC against Mr. Somerville and eight directors of the companies. Court further stated that directors of the company were also liable for breach the statutory duties stated under section 180 and 181 of the corporation Act 2001.
Part B
Answer 8: Phoenix prohibition can send educative message to the controllers of the company and their advisors, and it also has potential to increase the commitment of directors and officers towards compliance. Three broad factors are there which deals with phoenix prohibition, and these factors are normative, social and calculative. These factors motivated the regulated persons to comply with the law. It must be noted that, individual who is normative motivated is complied with their internalized values or morals. Perception of such individual in relation of immorality is generally influenced by the level of disdain with which it is viewed by the society. Phoenix prohibition can be considered as one way with which such perception related to immoral behavior can be prevented, and it also help in increased the perceived value for not engaging in such behavior. Therefore, it is clear that phoenix prohibition has potential to send such message.
Individual who is motivated by social factors has desire to be approved and respected by their colleagues and followers. It also includes prevention of any negative publicity and reputational damage that may be result from any undesirable behavior such as breach of phoenix prohibition.
Persons motivated by calculated factors are concerned with the compliance cost which can be imposed on them for their wrongdoing and that enforcement action will be commenced. However, it must be noted that it is difficult to detect these factors and prosecute, because wrongdoers has ability to hide behind the corporate veil.
There are number of cases in which businessman are indulged in the phoenix activity through their adviser. Therefore, both Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) and the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) mainly focus on the pre-insolvency adviser or experts of business restructuring. In 2017, almost 80 officers of ATO conduct raids on the two premises of Melbourne because of the pressure put on the pre-insolvency industry. This issue was seriously considered by the ATO for the purpose of conducting special investigation through phoenix taskforce.
Therefore, various steps are taken by government for the purpose of creating the legal phoenix activity prohibition, and various reports are published for developing the illegal phoenix activity prohibition because it harms number of people in the society. Current laws are not sufficient for prohibiting this activity as it requires more strict laws which deal with this activity in stricter manner.
Failure of current laws clearly shows that existing measures are not sufficient because phoenix activity cause harm on continuous manner to number of peoples, and it also state that there is urgent need of specific illegal phoenix activity prohibition. There are number of reasons because of which this specific prohibition is not introduced yet. Alternative approach is suggested for the purpose of sending message through specific phoenix prohibition, which means ‘anti-phoenixing’ message to the market. Message must be sent that profit earned from phoenix activity will be lost and Court imposed heavy penalties on the person engaged in such activity. Therefore, parliament also informs the ASIC about the priorities of the government and the seriousness of this behavior (Henderson & Hedges, 2017).
Answer 9: phoenix prohibition can be structured in following way:
Therefore, it is necessary to highlight the identity number of director so that it becomes easy for ASIC and other regulators to track the activities of the director. When ASIC has the knowledge regarding the activities of the director, then ASIC can also inform other authorities that particular company is under the surveillance. This option can increase the effective of investigations and tracking of companies conducted by ASIC and other authorities also.
References:
Anderson, H. & Hedges, J. (2017). Illegal Phoenix Activity: Is A ‘Phoenix Prohibition’ The Solution?. Retrieved on 31st August 2017 from: https://law.unimelb.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/2271613/Anderson-et-al,-Illegal-Phoenix-Activity-Is-a-Phoenix-Prohibition-the-Solution-2017-Company-and-Securities-Law-Journal-forthcoming.pdf.
Anderson, H. (2014). Defining and Profiling Phoenix Activity. Retrieved on 31st August 2017 from: https://business.monash.edu/__data/assets/pdf_file/0006/258936/defining-and-profiling-phoenix-activity.pdf.
ASIC v Somerville [2009] NSWSC 934.
ASIC, (2013). Small business-illegal phoenix activity. Retrieved on 31st August 2017 from: https://asic.gov.au/for-business/your-business/small-business/compliance-for-small-business/small-business-illegal-phoenix-activity/.
ASIC, (2016). Illegal phoenix activity. Retrieved on 31st August 2017 from: https://asic.gov.au/about-asic/contact-us/how-to-complain/illegal-phoenix-activity/.
Corporation Act 2001- Section 180
Corporation Act 2001- Section 181
CPA. New moves to stop illegal phoenix company activity. Retrieved on 31st August 2017 from: https://www.intheblack.com/articles/2017/06/06/illegal-phoenix-company-activity.
Mccoy, O. (2012). Phoenix Fever. Retrieved on 31st August 2017 from: https://www.claytonutz.com/knowledge/2012/september/phoenix-fever.
Essay Writing Service Features
Our Experience
No matter how complex your assignment is, we can find the right professional for your specific task. Contact Essay is an essay writing company that hires only the smartest minds to help you with your projects. Our expertise allows us to provide students with high-quality academic writing, editing & proofreading services.
Free Features
Free revision policy
$10Free bibliography & reference
$8Free title page
$8Free formatting
$8How Our Essay Writing Service Works
First, you will need to complete an order form. It's not difficult but, in case there is anything you find not to be clear, you may always call us so that we can guide you through it. On the order form, you will need to include some basic information concerning your order: subject, topic, number of pages, etc. We also encourage our clients to upload any relevant information or sources that will help.
Complete the order form
Once we have all the information and instructions that we need, we select the most suitable writer for your assignment. While everything seems to be clear, the writer, who has complete knowledge of the subject, may need clarification from you. It is at that point that you would receive a call or email from us.
Writer’s assignment
As soon as the writer has finished, it will be delivered both to the website and to your email address so that you will not miss it. If your deadline is close at hand, we will place a call to you to make sure that you receive the paper on time.
Completing the order and download